From Ground: Carefully water the drooping star-of-Bethlehem plant some time before the transplantation to dampen the soil, it will make the process smoother. Using your shovel or spade, dig a trench around the drooping star-of-Bethlehem, making sure it's wide enough to include all of the plant's root system. Push the spade under the root ball and gently lift it out of its original location.
From Pot: Use the trowel to loosen the soil all around the edge of the pot. Lean the pot sideway and gently tug the base of the drooping star-of-Bethlehem to dislodge it. If the plant is root-bound, it's okay to tap the pot to try to dislodge the plant.
From Seedling Tray: Water the drooping star-of-Bethlehem just enough to lightly moisten the soil. Gently grasp the drooping star-of-Bethlehem at its base and wiggle it to loosen it. Tilt the tray and guide the plant out, ensuring the root system is intact.