Lobed tickseed has basal, hairy, ovate to elliptic leaves that are approximately 3 inches (7.6 cm) long. The deep green leaves feature a unique pair of small lateral lobes at the base of the blade, resembling ears. This key identifying feature is crucial for recognizing the plant. The leaf surface is hairy, adding a distinct texture, and the lateral lobes make the leaves appear almost auriculate, enhancing their distinctiveness and aiding in easy identification for plant enthusiasts.

Lobed tickseed flowers are daisy-like, measuring up to 2 inches (5 cm) wide, with 8 vibrant yellow rays, each ending in a distinct three-lobed apex, encircling a bright yellow center disk. These charming blossoms typically bloom from April to June, gracing upright flower stalks that can reach 18 inches (45 cm) in height. While they lack a notable scent, their striking color and unique petal arrangement make them easily identifiable.

The stem of lobed tickseed is round and smooth, with a bright green color that stays consistent throughout its length. Typically, the stem's diameter ranges from 0.2 to 0.4 inches (0.5 to 1 cm) and it maintains a straight, unbranched pattern. The surface is sleek with no significant ridges or hairs, giving the stem its distinctive smooth texture. The stem supports the plant effectively, standing upright and robust without the need for external support.

The fruit borne by lobed tickseed is an achene, which is a small, dry, and hard fruit that contains a single seed. Typically appearing after the blooming period noted from June to July, these achenes are tiny, roughly 1/8 inch (3 mm) in size, and take on a brownish hue once mature. The texture is usually smooth with a slightly flattened shape, making them inconspicuous against the foliage. Each achene develops from the center of the spent flower head and can be seen as part of a collective cluster, often providing a subtle contrast to the vibrant floral displays of lobed tickseed.